Rhizamonitor
live

Run

Fix An owner-run plan's gate

done plan

Steps

  1. interviewdone3m 51s

    Nov 5 20:57 · said done and until held

  2. milestone-checkdone3s

    Nov 5 20:57 · exit 0

  3. reviewdone1m 10s

    Nov 5 20:59 · said done and until held

  4. criticdone43s

    Nov 5 20:59 · said done and until held

  5. checkfail0s

    Nov 5 20:59 · exit 1 rhiza: run review-check: review round 1 of run 01M6PQTGG41CN8MD2P3NTRJJQA has 2 confirmed finding(s); revise the plan and review it again: - f1 contradiction on owner-run-gate-accepts: Its parent plan-gate (01M5WSGDEE854PFE4BXJM13CWS) still states 'In a normal run they wait for the owner's rhiza accept --rule owner', while this leaf makes a normal run's gate accept under rule autonomy when rhiza.autonomy.accept is auto (its default). The plan does not update plan-gate's statement, so the model contradicts itself once the leaf lands. — confirmed: plan-gate (01M5WSGDEE854PFE4BXJM13CWS) still says 'In a normal run they wait for the owner's rhiza accept --rule owner' and its acceptance expects 'none accepted' for a normal run; this change set does not touch plan-gate's fields, yet its child owner-run-gate-accepts makes a normal run accept under rule autonomy when rhiza.autonomy.accept is auto (the default per internal/api/daemon_settings.go:82). The parent's statement and acceptance must be updated to say normal runs follow rhiza.autonomy.accept. - f2 outside-intent on autonomy-accept-rule: The leaf says rhiza accept AND reject take rule autonomy, but Decision owner-run-gate-auto-accept only rules on the accept the owner-run gate makes, the gate never rejects, rhiza.autonomy.accept governs accepting, and the acceptance check tests only accept. Reject under rule autonomy is outside the change set's intent (or, if kept, untested). — confirmed: Decision owner-run-gate-auto-accept rules only on the rule an owner-run gate accepts under; the gate never rejects, and the setting is rhiza.autonomy.accept. Rule autonomous covers both verbs in internal/api/lifecycle.go only because an autonomous run may make either move; nothing in the intent needs reject under rule autonomy, and the leaf's acceptance check tests only accept. The leaf should drop reject (or the plan must justify and test it). next: rhiza run status 01M6PQTGG41CN8MD2P3NTRJJQA

  6. revisedone1m 9s

    Nov 5 21:00 · said done and until held

  7. reviewdone1m 13s

    Nov 5 21:02 · said done and until held

  8. criticdone42s

    Nov 5 21:02 · said done and until held

  9. checkdone0s

    Nov 5 21:02 · exit 0

  10. gatedone16s

    Nov 5 21:03 · exit 0

  11. open-prdone9s

    Nov 5 21:03 · exit 0

  12. wait-prdone18m 32s

    Nov 5 21:21 · held after 37 checks

  13. pr-greendone1s

    Nov 5 21:21 · exit 0

  14. rebasedone27s

    Nov 5 21:22 · exit 0

  15. wait-rebaseddone12m 54s

    Nov 5 21:35 · held after 26 checks

  16. rebased-greendone1s

    Nov 5 21:35 · exit 0

  17. mergedone6s

    Nov 5 21:35 · exit 0

  18. close-outdone5s

    Nov 5 21:35 · exit 0

Log

log · tail
rhiza: step gate: entered, visit 1
Gated the plan of autonomous run 01M6PQTGG41CN8MD2P3NTRJJQA

- 01M6PQTKN5N2T2S3MGCK00YZMQ Fix An owner-run plan's gate: accepted (by the gate: proposed, accepted)

next: rhiza run status 01M6PQTGG41CN8MD2P3NTRJJQA
rhiza: step gate: pass
rhiza: step open-pr: entered, visit 1
Opened PR #312 (pushed 5864652): https://github.com/dphaener/rhiza/pull/312.
rhiza: step open-pr: pass
rhiza: step wait-pr: entered, visit 1
rhiza: step wait-pr: pass
rhiza: step pr-green: entered, visit 1
PR #312 at 5864652: 1 check passed
rhiza: step pr-green: pass
rhiza: step rebase: entered, visit 1
Rebased cs/fix-an-owner-run-plan-s-gate onto origin/main at dbaf107.
Pushed 893118f.
rhiza: step rebase: pass
rhiza: step wait-rebased: entered, visit 1
rhiza: step wait-rebased: pass
rhiza: step rebased-green: entered, visit 1
PR #312 at 893118f: 1 check passed
rhiza: step rebased-green: pass
rhiza: step merge: entered, visit 1
Merged PR #312 at 893118f as dfd42a2.
rhiza: step merge: pass
rhiza: step close-out: entered, visit 1
Removed worktree /home/rhiza/code/rhiza.fix-an-owner-run-plan-s-gate.
Rex tab window:01a1ad7d-8882-73e0-9bcb-d863b6e36752 was already closed.
Rex tab window:01a1ad7f-2ef1-700a-ace7-53e5de102060 was already closed.
Rex tab window:01a1ad81-1c3a-7bb3-9864-d40ab4192bcb was already closed.
Rex tab window:01a1ad82-382a-7645-95d1-1f17c3eb98ff was already closed.
Rex tab window:01a1ad82-d0ca-7bb2-84f1-050fcad17c89 was already closed.
Rex tab window:01a1ad83-eded-7b61-b02f-0265a9d7c29c was already closed.
Rex tab window:01a1ad85-081a-7107-a65f-21d23e44fc21 was already closed.
Deleted branch cs/fix-an-owner-run-plan-s-gate.
Deleted origin/cs/fix-an-owner-run-plan-s-gate.
Updated main in /home/rhiza/code/rhiza.
rhiza: step close-out: pass
rhiza: run 01M6PQTGG41CN8MD2P3NTRJJQA succeeded
Run 01M6PQTGG41CN8MD2P3NTRJJQA succeeded

- Workflow: plan
- Change set: 01M6PQTKN5N2T2S3MGCK00YZMQ: Fix An owner-run plan's gate
- Worktree: /home/rhiza/code/rhiza.fix-an-owner-run-plan-s-gate
- Autonomous: yes
- Started: 2026-11-05T20:53:58Z

## Steps

- interview (visit 1): pass, then milestone-check, session 627fef4e-be7d-42fa-908e-01a1ad7d72e6: said done and until held
- milestone-check (visit 1): pass, then review: exit 0
- review (visit 1): pass, then critic, session 1d4de7dd-4204-4ca5-97e3-01a1ad8101ca: said done and until held
- critic (visit 1): pass, then check, session b05226a1-0148-4a88-af77-01a1ad821d84: said done and until held
- check (visit 1): fail, then revise: exit 1
    rhiza: run review-check: review round 1 of run 01M6PQTGG41CN8MD2P3NTRJJQA has 2 confirmed finding(s); revise the plan and review it again:
    - f1 contradiction on owner-run-gate-accepts: Its parent plan-gate (01M5WSGDEE854PFE4BXJM13CWS) still states 'In a normal run they wait for the owner's rhiza accept --rule owner', while this leaf makes a normal run's gate accept under rule autonomy when rhiza.autonomy.accept is auto (its default). The plan does not update plan-gate's statement, so the model contradicts itself once the leaf lands. — confirmed: plan-gate (01M5WSGDEE854PFE4BXJM13CWS) still says 'In a normal run they wait for the owner's rhiza accept --rule owner' and its acceptance expects 'none accepted' for a normal run; this change set does not touch plan-gate's fields, yet its child owner-run-gate-accepts makes a normal run accept under rule autonomy when rhiza.autonomy.accept is auto (the default per internal/api/daemon_settings.go:82). The parent's statement and acceptance must be updated to say normal runs follow rhiza.autonomy.accept.
    - f2 outside-intent on autonomy-accept-rule: The leaf says rhiza accept AND reject take rule autonomy, but Decision owner-run-gate-auto-accept only rules on the accept the owner-run gate makes, the gate never rejects, rhiza.autonomy.accept governs accepting, and the acceptance check tests only accept. Reject under rule autonomy is outside the change set's intent (or, if kept, untested). — confirmed: Decision owner-run-gate-auto-accept rules only on the rule an owner-run gate accepts under; the gate never rejects, and the setting is rhiza.autonomy.accept. Rule autonomous covers both verbs in internal/api/lifecycle.go only because an autonomous run may make either move; nothing in the intent needs reject under rule autonomy, and the leaf's acceptance check tests only accept. The leaf should drop reject (or the plan must justify and test it).
    next: rhiza run status 01M6PQTGG41CN8MD2P3NTRJJQA
- revise (visit 1): pass, then review, session 957e5d7c-c100-4c44-adf5-01a1ad82bbe5: said done and until held
- review (visit 2): pass, then critic, session e2f2b1f6-1878-4b56-b12e-01a1ad83cc62: said done and until held
- critic (visit 2): pass, then check, session 5a73d2e8-0427-4d0d-980d-01a1ad84eb54: said done and until held
- check (visit 2): pass, then gate: exit 0
- gate (visit 1): pass, then open-pr: exit 0
- open-pr (visit 1): pass, then wait-pr: exit 0
- wait-pr (visit 1): pass, then pr-green: held after 37 checks
- pr-green (visit 1): pass, then rebase: exit 0
- rebase (visit 1): pass, then wait-rebased: exit 0
- wait-rebased (visit 1): pass, then rebased-green: held after 26 checks
- rebased-green (visit 1): pass, then merge: exit 0
- merge (visit 1): pass, then close-out: exit 0
- close-out (visit 1): pass, then end: exit 0

## Accepted in the owner's place

- 2026-11-05T21:03:00Z accepted change set 01M6PQTKN5N2T2S3MGCK00YZMQ (log entry 01M6PRB955VN7FEV5W5Z703R9C)

## Questions put to the arbiter

- question-627fef4e-1 (01M6PQXYWRF7FEA88EHHHBHDDG): Change set 'Fix An owner-run plan's gate' serves no intent yet. Which should it serve? (Recent Fix change sets serve milestone-25, 'The backlog is empty… bugs and polish'.) / When an owner-run (non-autonomous) plan's gate auto-accepts because rhiza.autonomy.accept is auto, which rule does the accept use? Rule 'autonomous' today is allowed only inside an unfinished autonomous run. / Before an owner-run plan's gate auto-accepts (accept auto), must the plan's review have passed, as the autonomous gate requires (gateReview: a review round, no confirmed finding without a question, no open review question)? — decision owner-run-gate-auto-accept

## Review rounds

- Round 1: 2 findings, 2 confirmed
  - f1 contradiction on owner-run-gate-accepts: Its parent plan-gate (01M5WSGDEE854PFE4BXJM13CWS) still states 'In a normal run they wait for the owner's rhiza accept --rule owner', while this leaf makes a normal run's gate accept under rule autonomy when rhiza.autonomy.accept is auto (its default). The plan does not update plan-gate's statement, so the model contradicts itself once the leaf lands. — confirmed: plan-gate (01M5WSGDEE854PFE4BXJM13CWS) still says 'In a normal run they wait for the owner's rhiza accept --rule owner' and its acceptance expects 'none accepted' for a normal run; this change set does not touch plan-gate's fields, yet its child owner-run-gate-accepts makes a normal run accept under rule autonomy when rhiza.autonomy.accept is auto (the default per internal/api/daemon_settings.go:82). The parent's statement and acceptance must be updated to say normal runs follow rhiza.autonomy.accept.
  - f2 outside-intent on autonomy-accept-rule: The leaf says rhiza accept AND reject take rule autonomy, but Decision owner-run-gate-auto-accept only rules on the accept the owner-run gate makes, the gate never rejects, rhiza.autonomy.accept governs accepting, and the acceptance check tests only accept. Reject under rule autonomy is outside the change set's intent (or, if kept, untested). — confirmed: Decision owner-run-gate-auto-accept rules only on the rule an owner-run gate accepts under; the gate never rejects, and the setting is rhiza.autonomy.accept. Rule autonomous covers both verbs in internal/api/lifecycle.go only because an autonomous run may make either move; nothing in the intent needs reject under rule autonomy, and the leaf's acceptance check tests only accept. The leaf should drop reject (or the plan must justify and test it).
- Round 2: no findings

## Sessions

- interview, session 627fef4e-be7d-42fa-908e-01a1ad7d72e6: tokens input 44, output 10292, cache creation 53992, cache read 1384695; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- arbiter, session 71523a03-c306-479d-829f-01a1ad7f1305: tokens input 18, output 3419, cache creation 33406, cache read 466198; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- review, session 1d4de7dd-4204-4ca5-97e3-01a1ad8101ca: tokens input 18, output 3855, cache creation 31467, cache read 448945; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- critic, session b05226a1-0148-4a88-af77-01a1ad821d84: tokens input 10, output 1481, cache creation 30665, cache read 233403; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- revise, session 957e5d7c-c100-4c44-adf5-01a1ad82bbe5: tokens input 20, output 2772, cache creation 32243, cache read 530001; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- review, session e2f2b1f6-1878-4b56-b12e-01a1ad83cc62: tokens input 24, output 3883, cache creation 39674, cache read 671067; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- critic, session 5a73d2e8-0427-4d0d-980d-01a1ad84eb54: tokens input 14, output 1128, cache creation 23898, cache read 330438; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0

Totals: tokens input 148, output 26830, cache creation 245345, cache read 4064747; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0