Run

Fix An owner-run plan's gate

done ship-change

Steps

build/builddone50m 43s
Nov 5 22:26 · 3 of 3 leaves passed
- Session 1finished · 2297818 tokens
- Session 2finished · 1405149 tokens
- Session 3finished · 795653 tokens
- Session 4finished · 815588 tokens
- Session 5finished · 569303 tokens
- Session 6finished · 865266 tokens
build/renderdone2s
Nov 5 22:26 · exit 0
build/checkdone3s
Nov 5 22:26 · exit 0
review/codedone8s
Nov 5 22:26 · exit 0
review/reviewdone34m 31s
Nov 5 23:01 · 5 of 5 checks passed
- Session 1finished · 523799 tokens
- Session 2finished · 876270 tokens
- Session 3finished · 694485 tokens
- Session 4finished · 220437 tokens
- Session 5finished · 684338 tokens
- Session 6finished · 261189 tokens
- Session 7finished · 579773 tokens
- Session 8finished · 622463 tokens
- Session 9finished · 805688 tokens
review/renderdone2s
Nov 5 23:01 · exit 0
render-prdone1s
Nov 5 23:01 · exit 0
open-prdone7s
Nov 5 23:01 · exit 0
wait-prdone17m 27s
Nov 5 23:18 · held after 35 checks
pr-greendone1s
Nov 5 23:18 · exit 0
signoffdone0s
Nov 5 23:18 · approved by rule autonomous
rebasedone1s
Nov 5 23:18 · exit 0
wait-rebaseddone1s
Nov 5 23:18 · held after 1 checks
rebased-greendone1s
Nov 5 23:18 · exit 0
landdone17s
Nov 5 23:19 · exit 0
wait-landeddone13m 54s
Nov 5 23:32 · held after 28 checks
landed-greendone1s
Nov 5 23:32 · exit 0
rebase-mergedone1s
Nov 5 23:32 · exit 0
wait-rebased-mergedone0s
Nov 5 23:32 · held after 1 checks
rebased-merge-greendone1s
Nov 5 23:32 · exit 0
mergedone5s
Nov 5 23:33 · exit 0
wait-maindone1s
Nov 5 23:33 · held after 1 checks
main-greendone0s
Nov 5 23:33 · exit 0
close-outdone5s
Nov 5 23:33 · exit 0
shipdone7s
Nov 5 23:33 · exit 0

Review

compliance passed

No findings.

quality passed

nit RunInfo.Accepts' desc still says 'an autonomous run accepted or rejected ... under rule autonomous', but an owner-run plan's gate now also journals accepted entries under rule autonomy, which land in the same list (run.go:2603). The text output's heading 'Accepted in the owner's place' still fits. Cycle 1's f1 is fixed: plan-workflow, plan-workflow-pr and plan-workflow-open now expect accepted/rule autonomy, and 146 plan/gate/inbox/accept testscripts plus go test -trimpath ./internal/api/... pass. internal/api/run.go:182

qa passed

minor With accept auto, an owner-run gate whose review has not passed (no round, or a confirmed finding with no question) drops gateReview's error and leaves the proposals with the same output as accept owner: neither the gate's output nor the inbox item says why nothing was accepted, so the owner cannot tell an unreviewed plan from the owner setting. internal/api/run_review.go:1308

scope passed

No findings.

model passed

minor The leaf (and Decision owner-run-gate-auto-accept) says rule autonomy is refused only unless rhiza.autonomy.accept is auto, but checkAutonomousRule also refuses it unless RHIZA_RUN names an unfinished run (any run, autonomous or not), and with no --reason it records 'rhiza.autonomy.accept is auto, run <id>'. autonomous-gate-rule spells out its run guard and default reason; autonomy-accept-rule's statement omits both, so the model understates the guard the code enforces. internal/api/lifecycle.go:285
minor Rule autonomy is accepted by every decision verb, so rhiza reject --rule autonomy also succeeds while rhiza.autonomy.accept is auto. No node says so: the leaf speaks only of rhiza accept, and reject-guarded-like-accept covers only rule autonomous. Either the model should record that reject is guarded the same way, or the code should restrict rule autonomy to accept (a setting named accept authorising rejections is surprising). internal/api/lifecycle.go:192

Log

log · tail

## Steps

- build/build (visit 1): pass, then build/render: 3 of 3 leaves passed
- build/render (visit 1): pass, then build/check: exit 0
- build/check (visit 1): pass, then review/code: exit 0
- review/code (visit 1): pass, then review/review: exit 0
- review/review (visit 1): pass, then review/render: 5 of 5 checks passed
- review/render (visit 1): pass, then render-pr: exit 0
- render-pr (visit 1): pass, then open-pr: exit 0
- open-pr (visit 1): pass, then wait-pr: exit 0
- wait-pr (visit 1): pass, then pr-green: held after 35 checks
- pr-green (visit 1): pass, then signoff: exit 0
- signoff (visit 1): pass, then rebase: approved by rule autonomous
- rebase (visit 1): pass, then wait-rebased: exit 0
- wait-rebased (visit 1): pass, then rebased-green: held after 1 checks
- rebased-green (visit 1): pass, then land: exit 0
- land (visit 1): pass, then wait-landed: exit 0
- wait-landed (visit 1): pass, then landed-green: held after 28 checks
- landed-green (visit 1): pass, then rebase-merge: exit 0
- rebase-merge (visit 1): pass, then wait-rebased-merge: exit 0
- wait-rebased-merge (visit 1): pass, then rebased-merge-green: held after 1 checks
- rebased-merge-green (visit 1): pass, then merge: exit 0
- merge (visit 1): pass, then wait-main: exit 0
- wait-main (visit 1): pass, then main-green: held after 1 checks
- main-green (visit 1): pass, then close-out: exit 0
- close-out (visit 1): pass, then ship: exit 0
- ship (visit 1): pass, then end: exit 0

## Leaves

- owner-run-gate-accepts (step build/build): passed: attempt 1: verifier passed
  - attempt 1 builder, session 4b5a3b76-f8bc-439f-9496-01a1ada397c7: pass (said done)
  - attempt 1 verifier, session 177ad7c7-6fd4-4ac0-b1a1-01a1adb0587c: pass (Evidence written by the verifier)
- autonomy-accept-rule (step build/build): passed: attempt 1: verifier passed
  - attempt 1 builder, session d70bc719-01f8-4082-9d35-01a1adb08b98: pass (said done)
  - attempt 1 verifier, session a3c54cf1-bdd9-4c51-b024-01a1adb569db: pass (Evidence written by the verifier)
- inbox-lists-owner-run-proposals (step build/build): passed: attempt 1: verifier passed
  - attempt 1 builder, session 65600f8b-34e6-48c5-a6ac-01a1adb59e6f: pass (said done)
  - attempt 1 verifier, session bba5fe8b-7f49-42ba-a981-01a1adb78c25: pass (Evidence written by the verifier)
- owner-run-gate-accepts (step review/review): open
  - attempt 2 fixer in cycle 2, session 5d7271de-aa84-485f-a4d2-01a1add8135c: pass (said done)
  - attempt 2 verifier in cycle 2, session 72caff76-c93e-4710-a4e7-01a1addaa9c7: pass (Evidence written by the verifier)

## Checks

- compliance (step review/review): passed after 1 cycle
  - cycle 1: passed, check session 18e77325-d839-411b-a061-01a1add23586 pass (said done)
  - round 1 (cycle 1): no findings
- quality (step review/review): passed after 2 cycles
  - cycle 1: failed, check session 943c649d-5bac-483e-a5dc-01a1add25fe7 pass (said done), critic session c64734e9-b878-4cf2-94ad-01a1add76f73 pass (said done)
  - cycle 2: passed, check session 971c85ab-8b0d-42c9-bcf3-01a1ade3924e pass (said done)
  - round 1 (cycle 1): 5 findings, 1 confirmed
    - f1 blocker at cmd/rhiza/testdata/script/plan-workflow.txtar:83 on owner-run-gate-accepts: Existing testscripts still expect an owner-run plan's gate to leave its change sets proposed, but with the default rhiza.autonomy.accept=auto and a clean review the gate now accepts them under rule autonomy. go test -trimpath ./cmd/rhiza -run 'TestScripts/(plan-workflow|plan-workflow-pr|plan-workflow-open)$' fails: plan-workflow.txtar:83, plan-workflow-pr.txtar:90 and plan-workflow-open.txtar:54 find no '"state": "proposed"' (the change set shows state accepted, rule autonomy). CI's make check will fail. Update these scripts to the new behaviour, or set rhiza.autonomy.accept owner where they mean to test the owner path. — confirmed: Reproduced at HEAD: go test -trimpath ./cmd/rhiza -run 'TestScripts/(plan-workflow|plan-workflow-pr|plan-workflow-open)$' fails at plan-workflow.txtar:83, plan-workflow-pr.txtar:90 and plan-workflow-open.txtar:54; each shows "state": "accepted" where the script expects "proposed". CI's make check would fail.
    - f2 minor at internal/api/run_review.go:1307 on owner-run-gate-accepts: With accept auto, the owner-run gate accepts the plan's change sets even while a question the planner parked is still open (resp.Open is non-empty, so the run also stops for the owner, exit 75). plan-workflow-open shows the change set accepted while the run waits on park-disk. gateReview only counts review questions as open. Autonomous runs already behaved this way, but owner-run plans used to leave such change sets proposed. Consider leaving them proposed while resp.Open is non-empty.
    - f3 minor at internal/api/lifecycle.go:285 on autonomy-accept-rule: rule autonomy is allowed from any unfinished run (a build, ship or review run, not only a plan run's gate) and for any change set, and accept=auto is the default. Any agent session with RHIZA_RUN set can therefore accept an arbitrary change set without the owner. The autonomyRule comment says the rule is for the gate of an owner-run plan, but nothing enforces that.
    - f4 nit at internal/api/lifecycle.go:283: Stale wording. checkAutonomousRule's doc still says it refuses unless the run is autonomous. gateReview's doc and its two errors (run_review.go:1471,1482,1495) still say 'is autonomous', and owner-run runs now reach them. The comment on plan.toml's gate step and the header of run-gate.txtar ('In a normal run it accepts nothing') no longer hold. The two consecutive 'if rule == autonomyRule' blocks at lifecycle.go:288-293 could be merged.
    - f5 nit at internal/api/run_review.go:1309: For an owner-run plan whose review has not passed, the gate drops gateReview's error and returns the owner accept next without saying why nothing was accepted. Under accept auto the owner cannot tell this case apart from accept owner.
  - round 2 (cycle 2): 1 finding, 0 confirmed
    - f1 nit at internal/api/run.go:182: RunInfo.Accepts' desc still says 'an autonomous run accepted or rejected ... under rule autonomous', but an owner-run plan's gate now also journals accepted entries under rule autonomy, which land in the same list (run.go:2603). The text output's heading 'Accepted in the owner's place' still fits. Cycle 1's f1 is fixed: plan-workflow, plan-workflow-pr and plan-workflow-open now expect accepted/rule autonomy, and 146 plan/gate/inbox/accept testscripts plus go test -trimpath ./internal/api/... pass.
- qa (step review/review): passed after 1 cycle
  - cycle 1: passed, check session 145392df-045d-4ca9-8ed5-01a1add28d2f pass (said done)
  - round 1 (cycle 1): 1 finding, 0 confirmed
    - f1 minor at internal/api/run_review.go:1308 on owner-run-gate-accepts: With accept auto, an owner-run gate whose review has not passed (no round, or a confirmed finding with no question) drops gateReview's error and leaves the proposals with the same output as accept owner: neither the gate's output nor the inbox item says why nothing was accepted, so the owner cannot tell an unreviewed plan from the owner setting.
- scope (step review/review): passed after 1 cycle
  - cycle 1: passed, check session 9a2cc451-41c9-4cb1-afde-01a1add2c8bb pass (said done)
  - round 1 (cycle 1): no findings
- model (step review/review): passed after 1 cycle
  - cycle 1: passed, check session 4ad6b65f-8d21-4717-beff-01a1add3069d pass (said done)
  - round 1 (cycle 1): 2 findings, 0 confirmed
    - f1 minor at internal/api/lifecycle.go:285 on autonomy-accept-rule: The leaf (and Decision owner-run-gate-auto-accept) says rule autonomy is refused only unless rhiza.autonomy.accept is auto, but checkAutonomousRule also refuses it unless RHIZA_RUN names an unfinished run (any run, autonomous or not), and with no --reason it records 'rhiza.autonomy.accept is auto, run <id>'. autonomous-gate-rule spells out its run guard and default reason; autonomy-accept-rule's statement omits both, so the model understates the guard the code enforces.
    - f2 minor at internal/api/lifecycle.go:192 on autonomy-accept-rule: Rule autonomy is accepted by every decision verb, so rhiza reject --rule autonomy also succeeds while rhiza.autonomy.accept is auto. No node says so: the leaf speaks only of rhiza accept, and reject-guarded-like-accept covers only rule autonomous. Either the model should record that reject is guarded the same way, or the code should restrict rule autonomy to accept (a setting named accept authorising rejections is surprising).

## Code checks

- step review/code: pass

## Sign-offs

- signoff (visit 1): approved by rule autonomous

## Sessions

- build/build, session 4b5a3b76-f8bc-439f-9496-01a1ada397c7: tokens input 64, output 11905, cache creation 60263, cache read 2225586; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- build/build, session 177ad7c7-6fd4-4ac0-b1a1-01a1adb0587c: tokens input 44, output 6873, cache creation 52083, cache read 1346149; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- build/build, session d70bc719-01f8-4082-9d35-01a1adb08b98: tokens input 26, output 3395, cache creation 38267, cache read 753965; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- build/build, session a3c54cf1-bdd9-4c51-b024-01a1adb569db: tokens input 28, output 4641, cache creation 33646, cache read 777273; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- build/build, session 65600f8b-34e6-48c5-a6ac-01a1adb59e6f: tokens input 20, output 2957, cache creation 33001, cache read 533325; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- build/build, session bba5fe8b-7f49-42ba-a981-01a1adb78c25: tokens input 30, output 4693, cache creation 34578, cache read 825965; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- review/review, session 18e77325-d839-411b-a061-01a1add23586: tokens input 16, output 2960, cache creation 41719, cache read 479104; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- review/review, session 943c649d-5bac-483e-a5dc-01a1add25fe7: tokens input 26, output 5861, cache creation 49637, cache read 820746; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- review/review, session 145392df-045d-4ca9-8ed5-01a1add28d2f: tokens input 20, output 6243, cache creation 49151, cache read 639071; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- review/review, session 9a2cc451-41c9-4cb1-afde-01a1add2c8bb: tokens input 8, output 1499, cache creation 30309, cache read 188621; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- review/review, session 4ad6b65f-8d21-4717-beff-01a1add3069d: tokens input 20, output 4727, cache creation 48648, cache read 630943; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- review/review, session c64734e9-b878-4cf2-94ad-01a1add76f73: tokens input 10, output 1565, cache creation 26003, cache read 233611; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- review/review, session 5d7271de-aa84-485f-a4d2-01a1add8135c: tokens input 20, output 3361, cache creation 32431, cache read 543961; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- review/review, session 72caff76-c93e-4710-a4e7-01a1addaa9c7: tokens input 22, output 4051, cache creation 31607, cache read 586783; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- review/review, session 971c85ab-8b0d-42c9-bcf3-01a1ade3924e: tokens input 24, output 3416, cache creation 44768, cache read 757480; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0

Totals: tokens input 378, output 68147, cache creation 606111, cache read 11342583; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0