Rhiza can manage and build

Rex tab window:01a1b161-6e60-7a7c-937d-3e8c2364ebdb was already closed.
Rex tab window:01a1b162-9564-7b1e-97d3-044779914476 was already closed.
Rex tab window:01a1b162-baf2-773a-a0bc-3220a016a3ed was already closed.
Rex tab window:01a1b162-de6f-7c0a-8328-80c1331ac2c2 was already closed.
Deleted branch cs/rhiza-can-manage-and-build.
Deleted origin/cs/rhiza-can-manage-and-build.
Updated main in /home/rhiza/code/rhiza.
rhiza: step close-out: pass
rhiza: run 01M6RMJ6P7EG0VXT1752W0H8NY succeeded
Run 01M6RMJ6P7EG0VXT1752W0H8NY succeeded

- Workflow: plan
- Change set: 01M6RMJ858AVSV2VA3K0TTV352: Rhiza can manage and build
- Worktree: /home/rhiza/code/rhiza.rhiza-can-manage-and-build
- Started: 2026-11-06T14:35:28Z

## Steps

- interview (visit 1): pass, then milestone-check, session 05fe56c8-8c19-4241-83c6-01a1b1494bc7: said done and until held
- milestone-check (visit 1): pass, then review: exit 0
- review (visit 1): pass, then critic, session c1b707ee-33b5-4721-aa92-01a1b154e1a7: said done and until held
- critic (visit 1): pass, then check, session 8fa9249e-32cf-466f-8836-01a1b1574d94: said done and until held
- check (visit 1): fail, then revise: exit 1
    - f4 contradiction on root-daemon-self-update: Contradicts the landed capability daemon-self-update (01M6FES89JR3Z5XA751AGCD3RV), which fast-forwards 'the main checkout' of the daemon's own repo under rhiza.daemon.selfUpdate in git config; the new leaf names self_update_project in rhiza.toml and never self-updates without one. The old node is not revised. — confirmed: Landed daemon-self-update fast-forwards the daemon repo's main checkout under rhiza.daemon.selfUpdate in git config; root-daemon-self-update keys it on self_update_project in rhiza.toml. Old node left unchanged by the plan.
    - f5 contradiction on root-daemon-round-robin: Contradicts the landed capability daemon-picks (01M61R7K5W91SXWWX8AGDZ01HC), which picks one repo's change sets in roadmap order until --max-runs (default 2). Round-robin across projects under a machine-wide maxRuns and a per-project max changes that rule, but daemon-picks is not updated. — confirmed: Landed daemon-picks picks one repo's change sets in roadmap order up to --max-runs (default 2); root-daemon-round-robin picks round-robin across projects under machine maxRuns and per-project max. daemon-picks is not updated by any plan change set.
    - f6 contradiction on vm-root-installed: Contradicts the landed capability rhiza-on-vm (01M6FESPV5PW1DHSM7HQC0F4CP): 'This repo's daemon runs as a service on the VM'. Change set 01M6RN474B5EXMX8NYHE7F62RV replaces rhiza-rhiza.service with rhiza-root.service but leaves rhiza-on-vm unchanged. — confirmed: Landed rhiza-on-vm says 'This repo's daemon runs as a service on the VM'; vm-root-installed uninstalls rhiza-rhiza.service in favour of rhiza-root.service. rhiza-on-vm is not revised by 01M6RN474B5EXMX8NYHE7F62RV or any other plan change set.
    next: rhiza run status 01M6RMJ6P7EG0VXT1752W0H8NY
- revise (visit 1): pass, then review, session 5cdfe59f-ac6e-4d95-a605-01a1b1585e0e: said done and until held
- review (visit 2): pass, then critic, session 6e1262f8-1f04-43d1-8c21-01a1b159f1a5: said done and until held
- critic (visit 2): pass, then check, session 88a0ecf3-757a-4cab-87dd-01a1b15c5e3f: said done and until held
- check (visit 2): fail, then revise: exit 1
    - f3 contradiction on root-daemon-lock: rhiza daemon outside a root exits 2, which breaks the unchanged acceptances of existing daemon leaves that run rhiza daemon --once in a plain repo with no rhiza.toml: daemon-pause.txtar, daemon-settings.txtar, daemon-event-hook.txtar, stage-autonomy and daemon-repo-session's script. The root-daemon change set has no leaf giving those scripts a root (a Setup fixture or a script helper). — confirmed: root-daemon-lock makes rhiza daemon exit 2 outside a root; existing daemon scripts (daemon-settings, daemon-pause, daemon-event-hook, etc.) run daemon --once in a plain $WORK repo, and the root-daemon change set adds no leaf giving them a root. Same gap as f2 on a different node.
    - f4 contradiction on root-daemon-rex-session: It names each project's session rhiza-<project> (the registered name, which project add --name can set). The existing daemon-repo-session, neither updated nor superseded, still says the session is rhiza-<repo>, named after the main checkout's folder, and that the daemon creates it and passes it as REX_SESSION. With --name the two disagree, and the plan never says which one rhiza inbox open and run open use. — confirmed: Landed daemon-repo-session (01M6FES3PKQCSNG9SEECK4G1R7) names the session rhiza-<repo> after the main checkout's folder; root-daemon-rex-session names it rhiza-<project>, and project add --name lets the registered name differ from the folder. No plan log references 01M6FES3PKQCSNG9SEECK4G1R7, so it is neither updated nor superseded.
    next: rhiza run status 01M6RMJ6P7EG0VXT1752W0H8NY
- revise (visit 2): pass, then review, session 4d0787bd-bb8c-4abe-8d95-01a1b15d6d40: said done and until held
- review (visit 3): pass, then critic, session 79f35fbb-d680-4d55-bd71-01a1b15f639b: said done and until held
- critic (visit 3): pass, then check, session d0f14bd5-76de-41bb-aa95-01a1b1615a17: said done and until held
- check (visit 3): pass, then gate: exit 0
- gate (visit 1): pass, then open-pr: exit 0
- open-pr (visit 1): pass, then wait-pr: exit 0
- wait-pr (visit 1): pass, then pr-green: held after 12 checks
- pr-green (visit 1): pass, then rebase: exit 0
- rebase (visit 1): pass, then wait-rebased: exit 0
- wait-rebased (visit 1): pass, then rebased-green: held after 12 checks
- rebased-green (visit 1): pass, then merge: exit 0
- merge (visit 1): pass, then close-out: exit 0
- close-out (visit 1): pass, then end: exit 0

## Accepted in the owner's place

- 2026-11-06T17:28:27Z accepted change set 01M6RN3M8EC8FEDEJ8X6YVCPZ4 (log entry 01M6RYF4B47N7K06MSJJ7TX8KV)
- 2026-11-06T17:28:37Z accepted change set 01M6RN3RCGAZ9RNTWTZPKFM61M (log entry 01M6RYFDYRP59KRD3NZRVNH5TM)
- 2026-11-06T17:28:45Z accepted change set 01M6RN3VGZ7D1JK4FRPNX21WHX (log entry 01M6RYFP1P2E1RF8JSGD058GHS)
- 2026-11-06T17:28:51Z accepted change set 01M6RN3ZBGYDW6KPBSES9A5JXS (log entry 01M6RYFVZS1B92KJTZEF733S0N)
- 2026-11-06T17:28:55Z accepted change set 01M6RN441P2Z865ZVKAS7X7GMG (log entry 01M6RYG0VWVZHXHVJXC8SQGG7V)
- 2026-11-06T17:29:02Z accepted change set 01M6RN474B5EXMX8NYHE7F62RV (log entry 01M6RYG71HP2KMN9WHNEK7H4MT)

## Questions put to the arbiter

- review-01m6rmj6-r3-f1 (01M6RP4X0H7YY4B9HFEGFYBBFY): Plan review round 3 left finding f1 (contradiction on testscripts-run-under-root): The leaf registers each script's $WORK folder as a project, but the scripts it must keep passing unedited (run-start, run-start-queue, daemon-repo-session, daemon-event-hook, ...) do `mkdir repo; cd repo; git init` and work in $WORK/repo. $WORK is not a git checkout, and $WORK/repo sits two levels under the root, so project-add-path refuses both (non-git folder; nested path). The repos those scripts use would not be registered projects, so runs-need-root and root-daemon-lock would exit 2 there. The leaf has to register the repo folder the script actually uses, or let the scripts change. The critic confirmed it: run-start, run-start-queue, daemon-settings, daemon-pause, daemon-event-hook, daemon-repo-session and stage-autonomy all do mkdir repo; cd repo; git init and work in $WORK/repo. testscripts-run-under-root registers $WORK (not a git checkout, and the repo sits a level below it), which project-add-path says is refused (non-git folder, nested deeper). The repos these scripts use would not be registered projects, so runs-need-root/root-daemon-lock would exit 2 and the 'unedited' acceptance cannot hold. How should it be settled? — open
- review-01m6rmj6-r3-f2 (01M6RP4X21TN1QGFWBWR8P2WJZ): Plan review round 3 left finding f2 (contradiction on testscripts-run-under-root): Its acceptance, and root-daemon-lock's, require daemon-repo-session.txtar to pass unedited. That script asserts the Rex session rhiza-repo, named after the checkout's folder. This change set retires daemon-repo-session and replaces it with root-daemon-rex-session, which names the session after the project's registered name (the $WORK folder, script-daemon-repo-session, under this Setup). The script tests a retired capability and would see a different session, so it cannot pass unedited. The critic confirmed it: daemon-repo-session.txtar asserts 'rex session new rhiza-repo' (folder-named). Change set 01M6RN3RCGAZ9RNTWTZPKFM61M retires 01M6FES3PKQCSNG9SEECK4G1R7 as superseded by root-daemon-rex-session (rhiza-<project>, the registered name). Yet testscripts-run-under-root and root-daemon-lock require that script to pass unedited, testing a retired capability. How should it be settled? — open
- review-01m6rmj6-r3-f3 (01M6RP4X9AKMA32RTMDSK9VRTQ): Plan review round 3 left finding f3 (contradiction on usage-settings): The updated acceptance calls for 'A new usage-settings.txtar', but cmd/rhiza/testdata/script/usage-settings.txtar already exists. The check should say to update that script to cover machine scope and rhiza.toml. The critic confirmed it: cmd/rhiza/testdata/script/usage-settings.txtar already exists; the updated usage-settings acceptance says 'A new usage-settings.txtar', which contradicts the code. How should it be settled? — open

## Review rounds

- Round 1: 6 findings, 6 confirmed
  - f1 contradiction on root-daemon-lock: Contradicts the landed capability daemon-lock (01M61R7J7KWQ20F4X22KTJ924R): 'rhiza daemon runs in the foreground, one per repo: it holds a lock under the git common dir'. The root daemon change set 01M6RN3RCGAZ9RNTWTZPKFM61M adds a root lock in <root>/.rhiza-root/ but neither updates nor retires daemon-lock, so the model would state both. — confirmed: Landed daemon-lock says one daemon per repo, locked under the git common dir; root-daemon-lock says never on a single repo, one lock in <root>/.rhiza-root/. No op in any plan change set updates or retires daemon-lock (grep of the plan's logs finds no reference to its ID).
  - f2 contradiction on root-daemon-settings-scope: Contradicts the landed capabilities daemon-settings ('The daemon reads its settings (paused, max runs, minimum free disk, permission mode, ...) from git config every poll'), usage-settings (rhiza.daemon.usage.* in git config) and web-serve-host (rhiza.web.host via rhiza daemon set). Under m29-settings-split these machine keys move to rhiza.toml, but change set 01M6RN3RCGAZ9RNTWTZPKFM61M leaves those nodes unchanged. — confirmed: Landed daemon-settings reads all settings incl. max runs, min free, permission mode from git config; usage-settings and web-serve-host are git-config keys. root-daemon-settings-scope moves maxRuns, usage, minFree, web host, selfUpdate, permissionMode, paused to rhiza.toml. None of the three landed nodes is revised by the plan (the only 'daemon-settings' hit in the plan logs is the command name 'rhiza daemon settings').
  - f3 contradiction on root-daemon-service: Contradicts the landed capability daemon-service-install (01M6FES1Z3GF9HJGVS4Y1S687B): 'writes and enables a systemd user unit that runs this repo's daemon (in the main checkout ...)'. The new leaf installs one rhiza-root.service with the root as working directory; the old node is neither updated nor retired. — confirmed: Landed daemon-service-install runs 'this repo's daemon (in the main checkout)'; root-daemon-service installs one rhiza-root.service on the root. The plan does not touch daemon-service-install.
  - f4 contradiction on root-daemon-self-update: Contradicts the landed capability daemon-self-update (01M6FES89JR3Z5XA751AGCD3RV), which fast-forwards 'the main checkout' of the daemon's own repo under rhiza.daemon.selfUpdate in git config; the new leaf names self_update_project in rhiza.toml and never self-updates without one. The old node is not revised. — confirmed: Landed daemon-self-update fast-forwards the daemon repo's main checkout under rhiza.daemon.selfUpdate in git config; root-daemon-self-update keys it on self_update_project in rhiza.toml. Old node left unchanged by the plan.
  - f5 contradiction on root-daemon-round-robin: Contradicts the landed capability daemon-picks (01M61R7K5W91SXWWX8AGDZ01HC), which picks one repo's change sets in roadmap order until --max-runs (default 2). Round-robin across projects under a machine-wide maxRuns and a per-project max changes that rule, but daemon-picks is not updated. — confirmed: Landed daemon-picks picks one repo's change sets in roadmap order up to --max-runs (default 2); root-daemon-round-robin picks round-robin across projects under machine maxRuns and per-project max. daemon-picks is not updated by any plan change set.
  - f6 contradiction on vm-root-installed: Contradicts the landed capability rhiza-on-vm (01M6FESPV5PW1DHSM7HQC0F4CP): 'This repo's daemon runs as a service on the VM'. Change set 01M6RN474B5EXMX8NYHE7F62RV replaces rhiza-rhiza.service with rhiza-root.service but leaves rhiza-on-vm unchanged. — confirmed: Landed rhiza-on-vm says 'This repo's daemon runs as a service on the VM'; vm-root-installed uninstalls rhiza-rhiza.service in favour of rhiza-root.service. rhiza-on-vm is not revised by 01M6RN474B5EXMX8NYHE7F62RV or any other plan change set.
- Round 2: 4 findings, 4 confirmed
  - f1 contradiction on root-daemon-settings-scope: It says daemon settings lists every setting as machine or project and enumerates both scopes (as m29-settings-split does), but existing settings get no scope: rhiza.daemon.trimGoCache (daemon-trims-go-cache, internal/api/daemon_settings.go:61, listed by daemon settings) and rhiza.eventCommand (event-hook-daemon, read from git config by the daemon). Under one root daemon it is undefined whether trimGoCache lives in rhiza.toml or a repo's git config, and whether the event command runs per project or once for the machine. — confirmed: internal/api/daemon_settings.go:61 defines rhiza.daemon.trimGoCache and daemon settings lists it, but root-daemon-settings-scope's machine list (maxRuns, usage, minFree, web host/port, selfUpdate, permissionMode, paused) and project list both omit it, and the updated daemon-settings node also omits it while its acceptance requires every key to show a scope. rhiza.eventCommand (internal/api/hook.go:29, read by the daemon) likewise gets no scope under the root daemon.
  - f2 contradiction on runs-need-root: rhiza run start and rhiza request will exit 2 outside a registered project under a root, but about 137 of the 273 testscripts (cmd/rhiza/testdata/script) run rhiza daemon, run start or request in a bare $WORK repo, and the testscript Setup in cmd/rhiza/main_test.go makes no root. No leaf in the plan says how scripts get a root, such as Setup writing a rhiza.toml and registering $WORK. So this leaf contradicts the acceptance of every existing run/request leaf whose script would now fail. — confirmed: runs-need-root (in 01M6RN3M8EC8FEDEJ8X6YVCPZ4) makes run start and request exit 2 outside a registered project; 137 of 273 testscripts call rhiza daemon, run start or request, cmd/rhiza/main_test.go Setup creates no root or rhiza.toml, and no plan leaf (grep of the plan logs for Setup/helper/fixture) gives existing scripts a root, so their leaves' acceptances would fail.
  - f3 contradiction on root-daemon-lock: rhiza daemon outside a root exits 2, which breaks the unchanged acceptances of existing daemon leaves that run rhiza daemon --once in a plain repo with no rhiza.toml: daemon-pause.txtar, daemon-settings.txtar, daemon-event-hook.txtar, stage-autonomy and daemon-repo-session's script. The root-daemon change set has no leaf giving those scripts a root (a Setup fixture or a script helper). — confirmed: root-daemon-lock makes rhiza daemon exit 2 outside a root; existing daemon scripts (daemon-settings, daemon-pause, daemon-event-hook, etc.) run daemon --once in a plain $WORK repo, and the root-daemon change set adds no leaf giving them a root. Same gap as f2 on a different node.
  - f4 contradiction on root-daemon-rex-session: It names each project's session rhiza-<project> (the registered name, which project add --name can set). The existing daemon-repo-session, neither updated nor superseded, still says the session is rhiza-<repo>, named after the main checkout's folder, and that the daemon creates it and passes it as REX_SESSION. With --name the two disagree, and the plan never says which one rhiza inbox open and run open use. — confirmed: Landed daemon-repo-session (01M6FES3PKQCSNG9SEECK4G1R7) names the session rhiza-<repo> after the main checkout's folder; root-daemon-rex-session names it rhiza-<project>, and project add --name lets the registered name differ from the folder. No plan log references 01M6FES3PKQCSNG9SEECK4G1R7, so it is neither updated nor superseded.
- Round 3: 3 findings, 3 confirmed
  - f1 contradiction on testscripts-run-under-root: The leaf registers each script's $WORK folder as a project, but the scripts it must keep passing unedited (run-start, run-start-queue, daemon-repo-session, daemon-event-hook, ...) do `mkdir repo; cd repo; git init` and work in $WORK/repo. $WORK is not a git checkout, and $WORK/repo sits two levels under the root, so project-add-path refuses both (non-git folder; nested path). The repos those scripts use would not be registered projects, so runs-need-root and root-daemon-lock would exit 2 there. The leaf has to register the repo folder the script actually uses, or let the scripts change. — confirmed: run-start, run-start-queue, daemon-settings, daemon-pause, daemon-event-hook, daemon-repo-session and stage-autonomy all do mkdir repo; cd repo; git init and work in $WORK/repo. testscripts-run-under-root registers $WORK (not a git checkout, and the repo sits a level below it), which project-add-path says is refused (non-git folder, nested deeper). The repos these scripts use would not be registered projects, so runs-need-root/root-daemon-lock would exit 2 and the 'unedited' acceptance cannot hold.
  - f2 contradiction on testscripts-run-under-root: Its acceptance, and root-daemon-lock's, require daemon-repo-session.txtar to pass unedited. That script asserts the Rex session rhiza-repo, named after the checkout's folder. This change set retires daemon-repo-session and replaces it with root-daemon-rex-session, which names the session after the project's registered name (the $WORK folder, script-daemon-repo-session, under this Setup). The script tests a retired capability and would see a different session, so it cannot pass unedited. — confirmed: daemon-repo-session.txtar asserts 'rex session new rhiza-repo' (folder-named). Change set 01M6RN3RCGAZ9RNTWTZPKFM61M retires 01M6FES3PKQCSNG9SEECK4G1R7 as superseded by root-daemon-rex-session (rhiza-<project>, the registered name). Yet testscripts-run-under-root and root-daemon-lock require that script to pass unedited, testing a retired capability.
  - f3 contradiction on usage-settings: The updated acceptance calls for 'A new usage-settings.txtar', but cmd/rhiza/testdata/script/usage-settings.txtar already exists. The check should say to update that script to cover machine scope and rhiza.toml. — confirmed: cmd/rhiza/testdata/script/usage-settings.txtar already exists; the updated usage-settings acceptance says 'A new usage-settings.txtar', which contradicts the code.

## Sessions

- interview, session 05fe56c8-8c19-4241-83c6-01a1b1494bc7: tokens input 80, output 29939, cache creation 85665, cache read 3206670; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- advisor, session 1df7d93f-8094-46c5-97f5-01a1b14accc6: tokens input 18, output 2993, cache creation 30888, cache read 442404; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- advisor, session 8987f2a1-9cac-4d1c-834e-01a1b14cc271: tokens input 22, output 3622, cache creation 38774, cache read 596235; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- advisor, session eff36498-f395-418e-a07f-01a1b14ebc94: tokens input 26, output 3447, cache creation 33450, cache read 690905; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- review, session c1b707ee-33b5-4721-aa92-01a1b154e1a7: tokens input 36, output 8317, cache creation 56561, cache read 1201740; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- critic, session 8fa9249e-32cf-466f-8836-01a1b1574d94: tokens input 20, output 3534, cache creation 34522, cache read 538722; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- revise, session 5cdfe59f-ac6e-4d95-a605-01a1b1585e0e: tokens input 18, output 5562, cache creation 46863, cache read 529046; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- review, session 6e1262f8-1f04-43d1-8c21-01a1b159f1a5: tokens input 36, output 9709, cache creation 69059, cache read 1267816; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- critic, session 88a0ecf3-757a-4cab-87dd-01a1b15c5e3f: tokens input 26, output 4604, cache creation 43910, cache read 779490; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- revise, session 4d0787bd-bb8c-4abe-8d95-01a1b15d6d40: tokens input 30, output 9660, cache creation 63758, cache read 1091186; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- review, session 79f35fbb-d680-4d55-bd71-01a1b15f639b: tokens input 22, output 7729, cache creation 54756, cache read 707145; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- critic, session d0f14bd5-76de-41bb-aa95-01a1b1615a17: tokens input 18, output 2703, cache creation 34214, cache read 482435; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- advisor, session 694b1589-337a-429b-86eb-01a1b162c2e2: tokens input 12, output 1771, cache creation 26748, cache read 287894; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- advisor, session b17f26ac-5cc3-485b-ba55-01a1b1628041: tokens input 14, output 3218, cache creation 27115, cache read 334669; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0

Totals: tokens input 378, output 96808, cache creation 646283, cache read 12156357; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0