The import guide's decision

Review round 2 of run 01M6S95D7KPHCXVGY1R8890DTJ passed: no confirmed finding
rhiza: step check: pass
rhiza: step gate: entered, visit 1
Gated the plan of autonomous run 01M6S95D7KPHCXVGY1R8890DTJ

- 01M6S95EWGHBTY9RSY63NX75AE The import guide's decision: accepted (by the gate: proposed, accepted)

next: rhiza run status 01M6S95D7KPHCXVGY1R8890DTJ
rhiza: step gate: pass
rhiza: step open-pr: entered, visit 1
Opened PR #336 (pushed 994f392): https://github.com/dphaener/rhiza/pull/336.
rhiza: step open-pr: pass
rhiza: step wait-pr: entered, visit 1
rhiza: step wait-pr: pass
rhiza: step pr-green: entered, visit 1
PR #336 at 994f392: 10 checks passed
rhiza: step pr-green: pass
rhiza: step rebase: entered, visit 1
Rebased cs/the-import-guide-s-decision onto origin/main at 3561446.
Pushed 7d38800.
rhiza: step rebase: pass
rhiza: step wait-rebased: entered, visit 1
rhiza: step wait-rebased: pass
rhiza: step rebased-green: entered, visit 1
PR #336 at 7d38800: 10 checks passed
rhiza: step rebased-green: pass
rhiza: step merge: entered, visit 1
Merged PR #336 at 7d38800 as c47d73f.
rhiza: step merge: pass
rhiza: step close-out: entered, visit 1
Removed worktree /home/rhiza/code/rhiza.the-import-guide-s-decision.
Rex tab window:01a1b292-fab6-7de8-a221-a96ab9b5d910 was already closed.
Rex tab window:01a1b294-2265-7a37-af24-1e01c61e8570 was already closed.
Rex tab window:01a1b295-e445-715c-9181-e2c851bb98c6 was already closed.
Rex tab window:01a1b296-f3c5-7385-a4ec-386bee46dc3e was already closed.
Rex tab window:01a1b297-8e1a-7295-a28b-427133c329f4 was already closed.
Rex tab window:01a1b298-9d36-715f-bf0f-77ab17c60fb2 was already closed.
Rex tab window:01a1b299-36ff-7ec2-967b-951c82d81dde was already closed.
Deleted branch cs/the-import-guide-s-decision.
Deleted origin/cs/the-import-guide-s-decision.
Updated main in /home/rhiza/code/rhiza.
rhiza: step close-out: pass
rhiza: run 01M6S95D7KPHCXVGY1R8890DTJ succeeded
Run 01M6S95D7KPHCXVGY1R8890DTJ succeeded

- Workflow: plan
- Change set: 01M6S95EWGHBTY9RSY63NX75AE: The import guide's decision
- Worktree: /home/rhiza/code/rhiza.the-import-guide-s-decision
- Autonomous: yes
- Started: 2026-11-06T20:35:29Z

## Steps

- interview (visit 1): pass, then milestone-check, session c7c3877a-453a-4754-9cde-01a1b292e12c: said done and until held
- milestone-check (visit 1): pass, then review: exit 0
- review (visit 1): pass, then critic, session 1bb5d836-9ab2-4238-b667-01a1b295cdd4: said done and until held
- critic (visit 1): pass, then check, session 8b9294b8-87f5-4645-b206-01a1b296dd20: said done and until held
- check (visit 1): fail, then revise: exit 1
    rhiza: run review-check: review round 1 of run 01M6S95D7KPHCXVGY1R8890DTJ has 1 confirmed finding(s); revise the plan and review it again:
    - f1 contradiction on import-owner-credited-decisions: The new leaf adds an owner-credited wording form for imported decisions that have no owner words (no quote), but the landed leaf import-autonomous-decisions says 'an imported decision with no owner words has no quote, a wording naming it as the agent's made autonomously and not confirmed by the owner', and the landed decision import-load-bearing-decisions says every imported decision is 'worded as the agent's and marked as made autonomously and not confirmed by the owner'. The plan's decision import-owner-credited-wording-shape keeps import-autonomous-decisions 'as it is' and neither amends nor supersedes import-load-bearing-decisions, so once this lands the model states both rules. The plan must narrow import-autonomous-decisions' statement to decisions the document does not attribute to the owner, and supersede or amend import-load-bearing-decisions. — confirmed: The change set's ops only create the question, the decision, the Source, the new leaf and serves links; it neither updates import-autonomous-decisions (whose landed statement gives every imported decision with no owner words the agent-made, autonomous wording) nor supersedes import-load-bearing-decisions (each imported decision 'worded as the agent's and marked as made autonomously'). The new leaf gives owner-credited decisions, which also have no quote, a different wording, so after landing the model states two conflicting rules; the plan's own decision even says import-autonomous-decisions 'stays as it is'.
    next: rhiza run status 01M6S95D7KPHCXVGY1R8890DTJ
- revise (visit 1): pass, then review, session c9a72258-cb9d-40ac-8998-01a1b29776f9: said done and until held
- review (visit 2): pass, then critic, session 5565d920-fa1f-4628-b37c-01a1b298867a: said done and until held
- critic (visit 2): pass, then check, session 68849948-7434-411a-87dd-01a1b299208b: said done and until held
- check (visit 2): pass, then gate: exit 0
- gate (visit 1): pass, then open-pr: exit 0
- open-pr (visit 1): pass, then wait-pr: exit 0
- wait-pr (visit 1): pass, then pr-green: held after 11 checks
- pr-green (visit 1): pass, then rebase: exit 0
- rebase (visit 1): pass, then wait-rebased: exit 0
- wait-rebased (visit 1): pass, then rebased-green: held after 23 checks
- rebased-green (visit 1): pass, then merge: exit 0
- merge (visit 1): pass, then close-out: exit 0
- close-out (visit 1): pass, then end: exit 0

## Accepted in the owner's place

- 2026-11-06T20:43:09Z accepted change set 01M6S95EWGHBTY9RSY63NX75AE (log entry 01M6S9KNBQ60CDXMYPBS8ANJ18)

## Questions put to the arbiter

- question-c7c3877a-1 (01M6S97XRGV8H0Y7ZHX2QS1H7H): Change set 'The import guide's decision' serves no intent yet. Which landed intent should it serve? (The import-procedure change set that built rhiza guide import served milestone-27 and m27-nebari-imported.) / How should the leaf be shaped for the owner-credited wording form in rhiza guide import step 4? / rhiza check today validates no wording form on imported decisions (no check code reads it), so both forms already pass. What should 'rhiza check must accept both forms' mean for the acceptance? — decision import-owner-credited-wording-shape

## Review rounds

- Round 1: 1 finding, 1 confirmed
  - f1 contradiction on import-owner-credited-decisions: The new leaf adds an owner-credited wording form for imported decisions that have no owner words (no quote), but the landed leaf import-autonomous-decisions says 'an imported decision with no owner words has no quote, a wording naming it as the agent's made autonomously and not confirmed by the owner', and the landed decision import-load-bearing-decisions says every imported decision is 'worded as the agent's and marked as made autonomously and not confirmed by the owner'. The plan's decision import-owner-credited-wording-shape keeps import-autonomous-decisions 'as it is' and neither amends nor supersedes import-load-bearing-decisions, so once this lands the model states both rules. The plan must narrow import-autonomous-decisions' statement to decisions the document does not attribute to the owner, and supersede or amend import-load-bearing-decisions. — confirmed: The change set's ops only create the question, the decision, the Source, the new leaf and serves links; it neither updates import-autonomous-decisions (whose landed statement gives every imported decision with no owner words the agent-made, autonomous wording) nor supersedes import-load-bearing-decisions (each imported decision 'worded as the agent's and marked as made autonomously'). The new leaf gives owner-credited decisions, which also have no quote, a different wording, so after landing the model states two conflicting rules; the plan's own decision even says import-autonomous-decisions 'stays as it is'.
- Round 2: no findings

## Sessions

- interview, session c7c3877a-453a-4754-9cde-01a1b292e12c: tokens input 30, output 5297, cache creation 36834, cache read 783453; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- arbiter, session 4bd43f67-acf3-4bbd-9b71-01a1b2940a31: tokens input 16, output 2916, cache creation 27436, cache read 388578; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- review, session 1bb5d836-9ab2-4238-b667-01a1b295cdd4: tokens input 14, output 2493, cache creation 28823, cache read 336129; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- critic, session 8b9294b8-87f5-4645-b206-01a1b296dd20: tokens input 12, output 1342, cache creation 31328, cache read 290039; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- revise, session c9a72258-cb9d-40ac-8998-01a1b29776f9: tokens input 16, output 3443, cache creation 37081, cache read 428083; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- review, session 5565d920-fa1f-4628-b37c-01a1b298867a: tokens input 10, output 1370, cache creation 34873, cache read 244331; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0
- critic, session 68849948-7434-411a-87dd-01a1b299208b: tokens input 10, output 736, cache creation 21670, cache read 224656; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0

Totals: tokens input 108, output 17597, cache creation 218045, cache read 2695269; helper tokens input 0, output 0, cache creation 0, cache read 0